Lockart, R. & McLeod, S. (2012, in press December). Factors that enhance English-speaking speech-language pathologists’ transcription of Cantonese-speaking children’s consonants. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology.
Purpose. The aim was to investigate speech-language pathology students’ ability to identify errors and transcribe typical and atypical speech in Cantonese, a non-native language.
Method. Thirty three English-speaking students completed three tasks in an
experimental within subjects design.
Results. Task 1 (baseline) involved transcribing English words. In Task 2
participants transcribed 25 words spoken by a Cantonese adult. An average of
59.1% consonants was transcribed correctly (72.9% when Cantonese-English transfer
patterns were allowed). There was higher accuracy on shared English
and Cantonese syllable-initial consonants /m,n,f,s,h,j,w,l/ and syllable-final
consonants. In Task 3 participants identified consonant errors and transcribed
100 words spoken by Cantonese-speaking children under four additive conditions:
1)
baseline, 2) +adult model, 3) +information about Cantonese phonology, 4) all
variables (2 and 3 were counterbalanced). There was a significant improvement
in identification and transcription scores for conditions 2, 3 and 4 with a
moderate effect size. Increased skill was not based on listeners’ proficiency in speaking another language, perceived
transcription skill, musicality, or confidence with multilingual clients.
Conclusion. SLP students, with no exposure to or specific training in Cantonese,
have some skills to identify errors and transcribe Cantonese. Provision of a
Cantonese-adult model and information about Cantonese phonology increased
accuracy.
